Remembering Brackenridge 1991 Floor Collapse and LODD

12-21-2009 9-53-23 PMRemembering Brackenridge, Pennsylvania December 20, 1991: Four Firefighters Killed, Trapped by Floor Collapse

Four volunteer firefighters died when they were trapped by a partial floor collapse during a structure fire in Brackenridge, Pennsylvania, on the morning of December 20, 1991. All four were members of a mutual aid truck company that had responded to the early morning incident and were assigned to prevent fire extension from the basement to the ground floor of a 2-story building. Although they were wearing full protective clothing and using self-contained breathing apparatus, it appears that they were overwhelmed by the severe fire conditions that erupted when a section of the ground floor collapsed into the basement. The collapse cut off their primary escape path, and the fire burned through their hose line, leaving them without protection from the flames.  

 SUMMARY OF KEY ISSUES

  • Situation: Fire in enclosed room in basement. Unable to locate fire because of smoke. Smoke and heat increasing, but no visible fire.
  • Structure: Appeared to be heavy concrete construction. Actually thin concrete floors supported by unprotected steel.
  • Contents: Furniture refinishing business. Quantities of flammable finishes and solvents in basement.
  • Exits: One entrance/ exit on each level; no alternate exits.
  • Structural Collapse: Floor section collapsed between interior crew and their only exit. Fire overwhelmed crew.
  • Rescue Attempts: Valiant rescue efforts proved unsuccessful. Unsure if missing members fell into basement or were trapped on ground floor.
  • Incident Command: No formal command system or personnel accountability in place. Chief of first-due company in command of incident; Assistant Chiefs assigned to basement and ground floor.
  • Information: No pre-fire plan and no detailed knowledge of occupancy. Clues of structural danger not recognized as fire conditions increased
  • Communications: Radio system inadequate for current needs.
  • Response: Independent volunteer companies. Mutual aid requested on arrival and additional companies called in succession.
  • Weather: Extremely cold night, predawn hours. Problems with frozen hydrants.
  • Water System: Weak supply. Extensive mutual aid and long relays needed to protect exposures.

The analysis of this incident provides several valuable lessons for the fire service. Unfortunately these are all revisited lessons, not new discoveries. These firefighters died in the line of duty, while conducting operations that appeared to be routine, and were unaware of the situation that was developing below them. They died in spite of the fact that they were experienced, they were operating with a standard approach to operational safety, and they were the object of repeated rescue attempts by highly capable comrades.

There are several factors that could have provided warning or changed the outcome of this situation. Like most accidents, this situation was the result of a number of problems that came together under the worst possible circumstances. Firefighting obviously involves inherent dangers that must be accepted by its practitioners. The important messages for the fire service are to identify risk factors in advance of an incident and to develop mechanisms to react appropriately when critical situations present themselves.

This situation bears distinct similarities to other incidents that have claimed the lives of several firefighters in the past. The lessons that must be derived from this incident are not a condemnation of the actions or judgment of anyone who was involved in the situation; they simply identify information that can help to prevent this type of accident from occurring in the future.

USFA Report; HERE

NFPA Summary; HERE

NFPA Report Order; HERE 

Brackenridge Pioneer Hose Co. Memorial, Pennsylvania, HERE

1 Comment

3 Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

background image Blogger Img

Chris Naum

Welcome to Commandsafety.com. The authoratative and informational site that provides leading insights on fire service issues related to Building Construction, Command Risk Management and Firefighter Safety.

FE Talk: Humpday Hangout

Categories
  • "firefighter safety" (126)
  • "health and safety" (22)
  • "pre-fire planning" (57)
  • "Safety Week" (13)
  • "Situational Awareness" assessment (72)
  • 911 (3)
  • Abandoned (3)
  • accident (1)
  • advocate (16)
  • Alert (1)
  • Architectural Design (15)
  • Arson (2)
  • assemblies (19)
  • behaviors (11)
  • Black Sunday (2)
  • Bronx (1)
  • Brooklyn (5)
  • building construction (185)
  • Building Construction for the Fire Service (182)
  • Building Construction for the Fire Srvice (6)
  • buildings (116)
  • buildingsonfire.com (202)
  • Charleston (5)
  • Christopher Naum (241)
  • close-call (25)
  • Codes (11)
  • Collapse (66)
  • Combat Fire Engagement (75)
  • command (4)
  • command presence (12)
  • command-leadership (28)
  • Company (8)
  • compentencies (43)
  • construction (97)
  • country (1)
  • courage (5)
  • courage to be safe (28)
  • culture (5)
  • decision-making (51)
  • decisions (3)
  • deconstrucion (1)
  • Deconstruction (2)
  • demolition (1)
  • Deployment (13)
  • destiny (4)
  • development (2)
  • Disaster Response (3)
  • duty (3)
  • dynamics (16)
  • education (11)
  • EGH (5)
  • Engineered (7)
  • Engineered Structural Systems (21)
  • engineered systems (9)
  • events (7)
  • explosion (8)
  • failures (28)
  • Fatalities (15)
  • FDIC (2)
  • FDNY (26)
  • FEMA (1)
  • fire behavior (77)
  • fire chief (1)
  • Fire Flow (6)
  • Fire Protection Engineering (15)
  • fire service (16)
  • Fire Service Tradition (22)
  • fire suppression (82)
  • fire-prevention-education (4)
  • fire-rescue-topics (11)
  • firefighter (21)
  • Firefighter Memorial Weekend (2)
  • firefighter-safety-health (77)
  • firefighting (43)
  • firefighting-operations (212)
  • fires (54)
  • first-due (25)
  • floors (20)
  • fortitude (9)
  • Future (1)
  • gas leak (4)
  • Generations (3)
  • hazards (6)
  • hazmat (1)
  • health (1)
  • high-rise (7)
  • Highrise (8)
  • History Repeating Event (31)
  • honor (14)
  • hydraulics (2)
  • IAFC (4)
  • IAFF (1)
  • in-the-line-of-duty (35)
  • incidents (3)
  • inspections (4)
  • leadership (6)
  • lessons (9)
  • line-of-duty (31)
  • LODD (84)
  • Lumber (8)
  • LVL (1)
  • major-incidents (32)
  • management (1)
  • Manufacturing (1)
  • mass-casualty-incident (6)
  • Mayday (30)
  • mentoring (4)
  • Multipl Alarm (2)
  • Naum (24)
  • near-miss (5)
  • NETC (1)
  • NFA (4)
  • NFFF (12)
  • NFPA (10)
  • NIOSH (30)
  • NIST (13)
  • NMRS (4)
  • occupancies (27)
  • Officers (3)
  • operations (12)
  • ordinary (4)
  • placard (1)
  • Planning (2)
  • pre-planning (20)
  • professional development (17)
  • Protection (1)
  • qualifications (4)
  • Recommendations (5)
  • Remembrance (18)
  • Renovations (2)
  • Reports (14)
  • rescues (1)
  • research (22)
  • residential (12)
  • response (2)
  • risk (7)
  • risk-based assessment (35)
  • Risk-preferring (6)
  • RIT (6)
  • roof (3)
  • Safety (9)
  • Safety Culture (20)
  • scenario (2)
  • size-up (26)
  • Skills (7)
  • special-operations (3)
  • Sprinklers (6)
  • staffing (1)
  • standpipe (1)
  • statistics (5)
  • strategies (21)
  • structure fires (22)
  • study (3)
  • survival (2)
  • symposium (2)
  • Systems (1)
  • Systems and Assemblies (5)
  • tactics (15)
  • Taking it to the Streets (12)
  • Technology (2)
  • technology-communications (1)
  • Ten Minutes in the Street (4)
  • timber (1)
  • Tpical Report Series (1)
  • tradition (6)
  • training (17)
  • training-development (30)
  • training-fire-rescue-topics (11)
  • Trapped (6)
  • Truss (6)
  • UL (3)
  • Uncategorized (150)
  • Urban Search and Rescue (1)
  • USAR (1)
  • USFA (9)
  • vacant (4)
  • ventilation (1)
  • volunteer (1)
  • Wind Driven (3)
  • Wind Driven Fires (2)
  • Wood Frame (1)
  • WTC (1)
  • Comments
    Remembrance: FDNY and Buffalo(NY) Double LODD from Floor Collapse | Buildingsonfire.com
    Buffalo, NY Three Alarm Fire and Double LODD Report
    [...] CommandSafety.com: Buffalo, NY Three Alarm Fire and Double LODD Report [...]
    2011-08-30 12:10:01
    Remembrance: FDNY and Buffalo(NY) Double LODD from Floor Collapse | Buildingsonfire.com
    Another Near Miss Floor Collapse
    [...] CommandSafety.com: http://commandsafety.com/2011/05/another-near-miss-floor-collapse/ [...]
    2011-08-30 12:09:27
    Remembrance: FDNY and Buffalo(NY) Double LODD from Floor Collapse | Buildingsonfire.com
    Eleven Minutes to Mayday; What You Need to Know
    [...] Eleven Minutes to Mayday; What You Need to Know [...]
    2011-08-30 12:09:06
    Remembrance: FDNY and Buffalo(NY) Double LODD from Floor Collapse | Command Safety
    Another Near Miss Floor Collapse
    [...] CommandSafety.com: http://commandsafety.com/2011/05/another-near-miss-floor-collapse/ [...]
    2011-08-30 12:01:27
    Remembrance: FDNY and Buffalo(NY) Double LODD from Floor Collapse | Command Safety
    Remembering Brackenridge 1991 Floor Collapse and LODD
    [...] CommandSafety.com: Remembering Brackenridge 1991 Floor Collapse and LODD [...]
    2011-08-30 12:00:05

    Christopher Naum's Discussions

    /* Removes Buzzboost Logo (MBT) */ div #creditfooter{ display: none; }
    Follow Chris Naum

    Mission Critical

    banner ad

    banner ad

    FirefighterNetCast on Blog Talk Radio

    Listen to internet radio with FirefighterNetCast on Blog Talk Radio

    The New Safety Formula: Bk = F2S

    Without understanding the building-occupancy relationships and integrating; construction, occupancies, fire dynamics and fire behavior, risk, analysis, the art and science of firefighting, safety conscious work environment concepts and effective and well-informed incident command management, company level supervision and task level competencies…You are derelict and negligent and "not "everyone may be going home". Our current generation of buildings, construction and occupancies are not as predictable as past conventional construction; risk assessment, strategies and tactics must change to address these new rules of structural fire engagement. There is a need to gain the building construction knowledge and insights and to change and adjust operating profiles in order to safe guard companies, personnel and team compositions. It's all about understanding the building-occupancy relationships and the art and science of firefighting, Building Knowledge = Firefighter Safety (Bk=F2S)

    Addressing Today’s Evolving Fireground

    Lectures,Seminars and Training Programs

    banner ad

    Taking it to the Streets Radio

    • banner ad
    • The Newest radio show on FireFighter Netcast.com at Blogtalk Radio… Taking it to the Streets with Christopher Naum. On the Air Monthly on Firefighter Netcast.com. A Buildingsonfire.com Series and Firefighter Netcast.com Production. Advancing Firefighter Safety and Operational Integrity for the Fire Service through provocative insights and dynamic discussions dedicated to the Art and Science of Firefighting and the Traditions of the Fire Service.

    QR Code for Commandsafety.com

    qrcode

    FireEMS Blogs eNewsletter

    Sign-up to receive our free monthly eNewsletter

    LATEST FIREFIGHTER NEWS

    HOT FORUM DISCUSSIONS

    LATEST ON FIRE ENGINEERING

    FEATURED DISCUSSIONS